Ten Years Later: The Wedding We Finally Got to Have

Our Anna Maria Island Vow Renewal | July 16, 2026

On July 16, 2016, Tim and I met.

Just a few months later, on October 20, we were married at the courthouse.

It wasn’t the big wedding with a beautiful dress, a walk down the aisle, and all our family and friends gathered around us. But we were married, and that was what mattered most.

Still, we’d always talked about having a wedding someday. Not because we needed another ceremony to make our marriage official, but because we wanted to experience all those little things we’d missed the first time around.

And for a while, we thought we were finally going to get that chance.

We planned a traditional ceremony and reception for August 2020. I bought my dress, we started making plans, and I was so excited to finally have the wedding we’d been talking about.

Then COVID happened.

Like so many other things that year, our wedding was canceled, and the plans we’d been looking forward to were put aside.

And then life just kept happening.

The years passed, our family grew, and somewhere along the way, life became a whole lot busier and more complicated than it had been when we first got married.

We experienced some of our happiest moments and some of our hardest. We welcomed more daughters, made memories, faced heartbreak, and found ourselves navigating things we never could have imagined back in 2016.

There were plenty of reasons to keep putting the wedding off.

But it was something we still wanted.

And eventually, we decided it was time to stop talking about it and actually make it happen.

Only this time, instead of the traditional wedding we’d originally planned, we decided to do something a little different.

A small beach ceremony in Anna Maria Island, Florida, surrounded by our closest family and friends.

And on July 16, 2026, we finally got to have the wedding we’d been waiting for.

Not exactly the one we’d planned all those years ago, but one that felt even more meaningful because of everything life had held in between.

Why We Chose Anna Maria Island

We first visited Anna Maria Island in May 2024, and honestly, that trip was a little bit of a disaster.

Between car trouble, unexpected stress, and everything else that comes with traveling as a family, it definitely wasn’t the smoothest vacation we’d ever taken.

But even with all of that, we fell in love with the island.

There was just something about the beaches, the water, and the whole atmosphere that made us want to go back. Before we’d even left, we were already talking about returning as soon as we could.

What we didn’t know then was that Anna Maria Island would be the last place we visited before our lives changed in ways we never could have imagined.

In the time between those two trips, we lost our daughter Hannah and later welcomed our rainbow baby, Bailey.

Our family had grown, but we’d also experienced a kind of heartbreak that changes the way you see everything.

Going back to a place we’d visited before all of that felt different.

It wasn’t just somewhere we’d enjoyed vacationing anymore. It had become a place connected to two very different chapters of our lives.

I’ve shared more about that in my post, Going Back to Anna Maria Island, because there’s so much more to the story of what that little stretch of Florida has come to mean to us.

When we started planning our vow renewal in October 2025, Anna Maria Island felt like the natural choice.

We didn’t want anything huge or extravagant. We wanted something beautiful and intimate, but still with all those wedding moments we’d missed the first time around.

Our girls dressed up and standing beside us. Our closest family and my best friend there to celebrate. A beautiful ceremony on the beach, followed by time together with the people we love.

Something simple, personal, and meaningful.

And after all those years of talking about having a wedding, it was finally becoming real.

We weren’t just planning a ceremony anymore.

We were planning a celebration of our marriage, our family, and everything we’d built together over the past ten years.

Planning Our Beach Wedding From Illinois

Planning a wedding in Florida while living in Illinois definitely came with its challenges, but once we decided on Anna Maria Island, things slowly started coming together.

We hired AMI Beach Weddings to handle the ceremony itself. Their package included a photographer, but we already knew we wanted Sam from Messy Momma Memories to capture our day.

Sam has been photographing our family for about four years now, so having her there felt like a natural choice. She’s captured so many memories for us over the years, and we wanted her to be the one documenting this chapter, too. So we brought her down from Illinois to photograph the wedding.

We took care of the rest of the planning ourselves, including finding somewhere for our welcome dinner and arranging a lunch celebration after the ceremony. You wouldn’t think choosing restaurants would be one of the hardest parts of planning a wedding, but somehow it was. Trying to coordinate everything from another state, especially with a larger group, took a little more work than I’d expected.

And then there was my dress.

I’d actually bought it back in 2019 or 2020 for the wedding we’d originally planned. It was a beautiful, slightly blush-colored gown with delicate lace details and a soft, romantic feel. I’d chosen it for a traditional wedding, never imagining that years later I’d be wearing it barefoot on a Florida beach.

But somehow, it worked perfectly.

After sitting unworn for all those years, I was finally going to get to wear it. And I was just as excited about that as I had been when I first bought it.

The girls were probably even more excited about the wedding than we were, especially when it came to being bridesmaids.

We chose a soft sea glass color for their dresses, but I wanted them to have some freedom to choose styles they actually liked. They also got to pick their own hairstyles, and all of them except Daniela chose little beach-inspired hair accessories to go with their dresses.

I loved watching them make those little decisions and get excited about being part of everything. It made the planning feel less like putting together a wedding and more like planning something special for our whole family.

Because that’s really what this was. Not just a celebration of our marriage, but of the life we’d built together.

The Days Leading Up to the Wedding

We arrived in Florida two days before the ceremony.

Tim, most of the girls, and I drove down, while Daniela flew with my parents. Tim’s parents flew down as well.

There was something exciting about finally having everyone there after months of planning. What had started as an idea back in October was actually happening.

The night before the wedding, we got everyone together for a welcome dinner at Daiquiri Deck. It was nothing overly formal, just a chance to spend time with the people who had traveled to Florida to celebrate with us.

After dinner, we met up with Sam for family pictures. She hadn’t been at the restaurant, but we wanted to take advantage of being in such a beautiful place and capture some photos of our family before the wedding day.

img_8910

And thankfully, the weather was on our side.

We’d been looking forward to spending time on the beach, and the days leading up to the ceremony had been beautiful. The morning of our wedding was no different.

We couldn’t have asked for better timing, because Tropical Storm Bertha would go on to affect the weather and currents in the Gulf during the rest of our trip. The water became rough, and some of our beach plans didn’t work out quite the way we’d hoped.

But on the morning that mattered most, the weather cooperated.

With everyone finally in Florida, the dresses ready, and the ceremony just hours away, everything we’d been planning for months was about to become real.

Of course, that didn’t mean the morning itself was going to be calm.

Not with a house full of girls, a nine o’clock ceremony, and me trying to remember approximately a thousand things.

The Wedding Morning

When we decided to have our ceremony at nine in the morning, I knew it would mean an early start.

I’m just not sure I fully appreciated how early.

My day started at two in the morning.

By 3:15, hair and makeup had arrived at our Airbnb, and we were getting everyone ready. Between all the girls, my best friend Natalie, and her daughter, there was a lot of hair to do and a lot of people to get dressed.

My dad was already taking candid pictures while we were getting ready, long before Sam arrived. I love that he was capturing those little moments in between everything else. Nothing posed or planned, just everyone getting ready and all the excitement and chaos that came with it.

000_2542

Sam arrived around six to start taking pictures, and I’m so glad she was there for those early hours, too.

Some of my favorite photos from the entire day are from getting ready. The girls having their hair done, the little details coming together, and the pictures with our moms. There’s something special about having those moments captured, especially after waiting so many years for this day.

Of course, while the pictures make everything look beautiful and peaceful, the reality was a little different.

I was running around trying to make sure everyone had what they needed, remembering things at the last minute, and somehow managing to misplace things we’d already packed.

At one point, I couldn’t find one of the girls’ shoes for lunch.

And after we finally got out of the house, I realized I’d forgotten my bouquet.

So we had to turn around and go back for it.

Which meant I was late to my own wedding.

I was excited, nervous, emotional, and completely stressed out all at once. I wanted everything to come together the way we’d planned, and after waiting so long for this day, I think I put a little too much pressure on myself.

But somewhere in the middle of all that chaos, there were these beautiful little moments happening around me.

The girls were excited about their dresses and hairstyles. Everyone was getting ready together. And I was finally putting on the wedding dress I’d bought years earlier for a ceremony that never happened.

It was a morning I’d imagined so many times, even if the reality involved a lot more running around than I’d pictured.

Finally Walking Down the Aisle

Tim and I had seen each other that morning, but there was one thing I’d managed to keep a complete secret from him for years.

My wedding dress.

He had never seen it. Not on me, not hanging up, not even in a picture. Somehow, through all the years since I’d bought it, I’d managed to keep it that way.

I did have a little fun with him, though.

At one point, while we were watching Say Yes to the Dress, he made a comment about a dress he didn’t like. Naturally, I decided to convince him that mine looked something like it. I told him it had long sleeves and was a little yellowish.

It became a running joke, but I wasn’t about to ruin the surprise.

After all those years of waiting to wear that dress, I wanted the first time he saw it to be when I was walking down the aisle.

And I was finally going to get to do that with my dad beside me.

That ended up being my favorite part of the entire day.

Although, if you know me, you probably know that being the center of attention isn’t exactly my favorite thing.

I don’t love having everyone looking at me, and I especially don’t like people watching me when I’m emotional.

So there I was, about to experience something I’d wanted for years, while also being incredibly nervous about having all those eyes on me.

But once we were there, everything started to feel real.

The beach was beautiful, the weather had cooperated, and our family was gathered together for something we’d talked about for so long.

The girls looked beautiful in their sea glass dresses.

Brooke carried Bailey down the beach because Bailey wasn’t interested in walking on the sand. Natalie’s daughter walked down on her own, tossing flower petals along the way.

And then it was my turn.

Walking beside my dad, looking toward Tim, and seeing our girls there was one of those moments I know I’ll always remember.

Ten years earlier, we’d gotten married at the courthouse without any of this.

And now, after everything that had happened in between, we were finally getting to experience it.

For all the stress of the morning, the forgotten bouquet, and the things that hadn’t gone quite according to plan, none of that mattered anymore.

We were there.

And in that moment, everything felt perfect.

A Ceremony That Was Ours

One of the things I loved most about our ceremony was how personal it felt.

Before the wedding, AMI Beach Weddings had sent us questionnaires to fill out about our relationship, our marriage, and our family. Our officiant used those answers to put together a ceremony that reflected who we were and the life we’d built together.

We didn’t write our own vows, but hearing pieces of our story woven into the ceremony made it feel so much more personal.

img_9487

And of course, with a family our size, there was bound to be a little chaos.

Bailey wasn’t particularly interested in sitting quietly while Mom and Dad got married. She was crabby, wanted me, and eventually ended up in my arms for part of the ceremony.

Including our family sand ceremony.

We’d wanted the girls to be part of the ceremony in a meaningful way, and having all of us participate in pouring the sand was something I’d really been looking forward to.

Was it the most graceful sand ceremony ever? Probably not. But there I was, holding Bailey while we all poured our sand together, and somehow that felt pretty fitting for our family.

img_9553

Our girls are such a huge part of our lives, and having them involved in something that meant so much to us made the day even more special.

And although Hannah couldn’t physically be there, we made sure she was included, too.

We had a special place for her, and our officiant acknowledged her during the ceremony. Those details meant so much to us, and I plan to share more about them in a separate post because there’s a lot more I want to say about that part of our day.

For all the nerves, excitement, and stress leading up to the wedding, I remember standing there feeling like everything was exactly how it should be.

Our girls were there. Our parents and family were there. Natalie and her family were there, too. We were surrounded by people who loved us, standing on a beautiful beach, finally having the wedding we’d talked about for so many years.

And in that moment, I wasn’t thinking about the forgotten bouquet, how late we’d been, or any of the things I’d stressed over that morning.

I was just happy.

We finished the ceremony with a kiss, walked back down the beach together, and then spent some time taking pictures with everyone.

A Few More Memories on the Beach

After the ceremony, we took our wedding pictures, along with family photos and pictures of the girls.

I’d been looking forward to having these photos for years. Not just pictures of Tim and me dressed up, but pictures of all of us together on a day that meant so much to our family.

Some of my favorites are the little moments from throughout the morning, along with the pictures of us on the beach after the ceremony.

Of course, it was July in Florida, and by the time we were finishing up, the heat was definitely catching up with me.

I absolutely loved my dress, but it was heavy. Between the dress, the sand, and the Florida heat, I was more than ready to get somewhere with air conditioning.

Thankfully, we wrapped up the pictures before I completely melted.

And we still had a wedding lunch to get to.

Lunch, Cake, and a Little More Celebrating

After the ceremony, we headed to Floridays, the restaurant connected to the Margaritaville hotel in Bradenton, for our wedding lunch.

We had a private section for our group, which was exactly what we needed. After such an early morning, it was nice to sit down, cool off, and spend time with everyone without having to worry about what came next.

Natalie had made our wedding cake, and it was absolutely beautiful.

She created a beach-inspired cake with flowers and a butterfly tucked among them in honor of Hannah. It was such a sweet, thoughtful detail, and it meant even more knowing she’d made it herself.

Screenshot

We had three flavors—chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry lemonade—and they were all part of a cake that fit our little beach wedding perfectly.

Tim gave a speech that was sweet and funny, thanking everyone for coming all the way to Florida to celebrate with us.

And then there was Scarlett.

She’d wanted to give a speech, too, and had every intention of doing it. But when the moment came, she stood up and decided she wasn’t quite ready after all.

I couldn’t help but laugh. It was one of those little moments that might not have been part of the plan, but made the day feel even more like us.

img_9930

We ate, had cake, talked, laughed, and finally had a chance to enjoy being with everyone without rushing around trying to get somewhere.

There was no big reception, no dancing, and no elaborate schedule.

Just a really nice lunch with the people who had come to celebrate with us.

And honestly, I loved it that way.

The Rest of Our Wedding Day

After lunch, we headed back to the Airbnb.

We’d been awake since the middle of the night, spent hours getting ready, had our ceremony, taken pictures in the Florida heat, and celebrated over lunch.

And all I wanted to do was get in the pool.

Swimming has always been relaxing to me, and after such a busy, emotional morning, being able to change out of my wedding dress and spend some time in the water sounded pretty perfect.

So that’s exactly what we did.

Some of our family stopped by for a little while before leaving to catch their flights, and later Natalie and her family came over to spend more time with us.

I loved that we didn’t have anything else planned for the day. There was no rushing off to another event or worrying about what still needed to be done.

The wedding was over, everything had gone beautifully, and we could finally just enjoy ourselves.

After months of planning and a morning that felt like it went by in a blur, spending the afternoon swimming and being together was exactly what I needed.

Ten Years Later

Looking back on our wedding day, it’s funny how some of the things I remember most aren’t necessarily the big, planned moments.

It’s my dad taking candid pictures while we were getting ready. The girls being excited about their dresses and hair. Forgetting my bouquet and having to turn around. Tim finally seeing the dress I’d kept hidden from him for years.

It’s Brooke carrying Bailey down the beach, Bailey wanting me during the ceremony, and Scarlett changing her mind about giving a speech.

And it’s everyone being there.

Our girls, our parents, our family, Natalie and her family. People who had taken time out of their lives to travel to Florida and share this day with us.

That meant more to me than I think I could ever really put into words.

But my favorite moment will always be walking down the aisle with my dad.

I’d waited so long to experience that. And even though I was nervous about everyone watching me, I’m so grateful I finally got to have that moment.

When Tim and I got married at the courthouse in 2016, we had no idea what the next ten years would look like.

We didn’t know how much our family would grow, all the places we’d go, the memories we’d make, or the heartbreak we’d experience along the way.

And we certainly didn’t know that the wedding we’d eventually have would be on a beach in Florida, with our daughters standing beside us.

The wedding we’d planned for 2020 would have been beautiful, and there’s a part of me that will always wonder what that day might have looked like.

But I’m so glad we got to have this one.

I’m glad our girls were old enough to be excited about it and be part of the planning. I’m glad we were able to have our parents, family, and Natalie and her family there. And I’m glad we got to celebrate in a place that has become so meaningful to us.

It wasn’t a perfectly calm morning, and not every little thing went according to plan.

But the parts that mattered were everything I’d hoped they’d be.

Ten years after we met, I finally got to wear my wedding dress, walk down the aisle with my dad, and celebrate the marriage and family Tim and I have built together.

And when I look back at that day, more than anything else, I think about how happy I was to finally be there, surrounded by the people we love.

It was a long time coming, and I’m so glad we did it.

Stay a little longer.

Get new stories from All That We Hold delivered to your inbox.